cuốn sách thử nghiệm dựa «Spiral
Dynamics: Mastering Values, Leadership,
and Change» (ISBN-13: 978-1405133562)
Nhà tài trợ

When the HR Influencer and the AI Disagree: Assessing the Credibility of a Viral HR Statistic on Stress and Turnover

HR analytics is a powerful tool that can help organizations make data-driven decisions about their workforce. However, ensuring that the data being used is accurate and reliable is crucial. In this scenario, an HR influencer stated, "Stress factors explain up to 9% of turnover," based on an article [1] with many numbers. This statistic caught your attention, as reducing turnover is crucial for controlling costs and retaining talent.  As a responsible manager, you decided to check the validity of this statement by consulting with three different AIs. Unfortunately, none of the AIs provided positive confirmation of the statement.


This leaves you uncertain about who to trust more – the HR influencer or the skeptical AIs. The HR influencer presented himself as an authority but did not share proof. The AIs admit the limits of what claims they can validate based on accessible knowledge bases. As a decision-maker, you cannot afford to use statistics that are unfounded or risk-making choices without empirical evidence.


To evaluate who to trust, it is essential to consider the source of the statement and the data being used. The HR influencer who made the statement did not explain how they arrived at the 9% figure, so it is unclear what data they used to support their claim. On the other hand, the AIs utilized data from a meta-analysis of turnover antecedents, which is a comprehensive review of the predictive strength of numerous turnover antecedents. The meta-analysis did not provide a specific percentage for stress factors explaining turnover, but it did identify various moderators of antecedent-turnover correlations.


This information makes it more reasonable to trust the AIs that provided arguments refuting the statement. The meta-analysis used by the AIs is a more reliable data source than an HR influencer who did not explain their methodology. It is essential to use accurate and reliable data when making decisions that will have financial and non-financial consequences on the workforce.


Anecdotes and hearsay do not justify budget expenditures or workforce structuring that impacts real employees. As an ethical leader, you prioritize transparency and credible proof over assumptions or rules of thumb when shaping internal policies. A statement may sound impactful, but the devil is in the details when basing business decisions on statistics.


In conclusion, HR analytics is a powerful tool to help organizations make data-driven decisions about their workforce. However, ensuring that the data used is accurate and reliable is essential. In this scenario, it is more reasonable to trust the AIs that provided arguments refuting the statement that "Stress factors explain up to 9% of turnover" based on a meta-analysis of turnover antecedents. It is essential to use accurate and reliable data when making decisions that will affect the workforce.



[1] Source: Griffeth, R. W., Hom, P. W., & Gaertner, S. (2000). A meta-analysis of antecedents and correlates of employee turnover: Update, moderator tests, and research implications for the next millennium. Journal of management, 26(3), 463-488.(https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/014920630002600305) 

2023.12.18
Valerii Kosenko
Chủ sở hữu sản phẩm SaaS SDTEST®

Valerii có đủ tiêu chuẩn trở thành nhà tâm lý học sư phạm xã hội vào năm 1993 và từ đó đã áp dụng kiến ​​thức của mình vào quản lý dự án.
Valerii có bằng Thạc sĩ và chứng chỉ quản lý dự án và chương trình vào năm 2013. Trong chương trình Thạc sĩ, anh đã làm quen với Lộ trình Dự án (GPM Deutsche Gesellschaft für Projektmanagement e. V.) và Spiral Dynamics.
Valerii là tác giả khám phá sự không chắc chắn của V.U.C.A. khái niệm sử dụng Động lực xoắn ốc và thống kê toán học trong tâm lý học và 38 cuộc thăm dò quốc tế.
Bài này có 0 Bình luận
Trả lời
Hủy trả lời
Để lại nhận xét của bạn
×
Bạn thấy lỗi
Kiến nghị VERSION ĐÚNG BẠN
Nhập e-mail của bạn như mong muốn
Gửi
hủy bỏ
Bot
sdtest
1
Chào bạn! Hãy để tôi hỏi bạn, bạn đã quen thuộc với động lực xoắn ốc?